No Magic Bullet;
I am all too familiar with kold cutters. They dull just like anything else and become worthless. Aluminum bars seem to work best.
I had been wondering about the aluminum bar type anti slip approach myself. I've tried many different cleats and have lost some of every brand. I don't think loss is related to anything other than that we are inserting these small screws into a rubber like substrate and they are pulled out as they get scuffed & torqued as we walk. I may try adhesive on the threads when I apply more this winter.
This past season I had a fellow with me who had the aluminum bars on his wading boots. I did not know this until I found one lying amongst the rocks in the river. All I saw was bright metal so I reached in and snatched it only to realize what it was. There on the bottom were a couple screws as well. Before the day was done I had collected a second of the bars and returned both to the man.
What that told me was that as of this time there is no perfect method of applying a stud - cleat or bar to our wading boots. I have found that the rather costly Simms hard bite star cleat stays in longer than any other that I have tried. They have a slightly lower profile which no doubt lends itself to their longevity but because of the low profile may not grip as well as others. I wade with the phrase that Dirty Harry kept repeating in the movie Magnum Force, "A man's gotta know his limitations". And that's what I've learned about cleats. One more thing; the factory cleated boots that Orvis sold years ago, the Hennery's Fork boot, they were the best I ever had and they were on a rubber soled boot. They never came out, they worked well and I was very disappointed to learn they were no longer offered............. Typical huh? Worked great, discontinued :Eyecrazy: