||LinkBack||Thread Tools||Rating:||Display Modes|
|Originator: John||Date: 4/21/2000 3:41 PM|
I recently called a reel manufacturer to enquire about using one of their reels on a new 15' rod that I have ordered. The person answering the phone seemed very knowledgable and stated that their new 4" reel designed for 12 and 13 weight lines would probably be too light for a 15" rod and would not balance it. The reel weighs about 8 1/2 ounces without any line. Their new 3.5" reel designed for 10 and 11 wieght lines is even lighter.
I am currently using a 6 oz. reel on a 14' 9wt, and cannot say that balance has been a problem. Since the fulcrum on a two-hander must change with the cast, how important do you find balance to be, and what weight reels are you using? Thanks
|Originator: bubba||Date: 4/22/2000 2:17 AM|
reels and spey rods... i think that a reel for a spey rod's real puropse (pun) is actually to balance the rod... the real balance should be compared with about 60-70 feet of line out. i think that large arbor adaptations of regular reels are actually a disadvantage, as the additional backing is good for weight and balance.
i have found that the many reels are actually too light to properly balance larger rods. a reel which is too light will definitely cause the rod to feel tip heavy, and from personal experience, this has caused some pretty severe carpal tunnel symptoms to develop over long days of casting.
the greatest spey caster of all time, alexander grant, actually used to counterbalance his rods by adding weights on the butt cap of his longer rods...
some of the larger and heavier saltwater reels (e.g. abel, charltons, tibors, pates), as well as some of the larger and older hardy bougle's seem to work pretty well. for several 15 foot rods, the largest teton and tioga reels are a decent low cost alternative...
also remember that spey lines take up a LOT more room on a reel, much bigger is better!
i don't know if this is of any use, but good luck!
|Originator: J_D||Date: 6/2/2000 12:14 AM|
I agree with Bubba. Try working a fly through the swing a couple of times with an unbalanced outfit and you will understand why the balance thing is so important. You will want to hold the rod as far up on the grip as possible, and with the line out on the water, it should balance. Remember too that the river is adding it's pull. Not quite the same as when on the lawn.
I put a Bauer M6 on my 9140 with 250 yards of 30# backing and the extended belly windcutter.And an M5 on a 12ft 7/8 wt rod I have. The new line of Redington reels has several possibilitie also. Some people have used the Ross saltwater and the old Lamson LP5 Spey was often used. I looked at the new Lamson Litespeed, but thought it would be too light.
New reels are coming out all the time so I might have missed some but this should at least give you a starting point.
|Originator: Per Stadigh||Date: 6/2/2000 6:40 AM|
Bubba and I have touched this subject over e-mail. My view is that the lighter overall weight the kit has the better one is off.
Possibly this problem is more relevant for those of you that stick to full length lines (as should be known by now am I am a stern user of tailored shooting heads.....)
If one actually feels better off with a "balanced" rod&reel combo, that is fine enogh. But then I strongly question if the extra weight needed should come from the reel. In my view it must be much better to add this weight to the very butt where the least of it is needed.
Sorry, but I have to be off for office in a few minutes. I am keen to continue this.
|Originator: Andre||Date: 6/2/2000 4:07 PM|
|Originator: Andre||Date: 6/2/2000 4:24 PM|
Your mention of reduced tippets breaking due to start up of the drag provides for more questions.
1, Are you fishing a low rod tip or raised tip? Generally speaking
2, Do you advocate using a loop of line under the finger?
From my limited experience I feel I have a higher hooking to "grab" and a higher landing percentage with the rod tip about eye level and a small loop. I attribute this to providing a "soft" line that allow the fish to turn on the fly. Usually most of the Northwesterns I see and fish with keep a tight line with the tip of the rod just of the water. While I agree one has a better feeling of the tension on the line I question my hooking to "grab" percentages using this method. In extremely cold conditions with lethargic fish there may not be a difference.
To bring this back to the tippet arena. Doesn't this also allow the tip to do one of its jobs and protect the tippet?
gladly still learning
|Originator: Dana||Date: 6/2/2000 10:45 PM|
Join Date: Feb 2002
Join Date: Feb 2002
For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome