Removing and replacing the bookkeeper, or covering the area with a decorative wrap wouldn’t be that difficult, the sticker Michu be tougher (although, again, cover it with a decorative wrap).
I wouldn't’ talk to Bob and Steve, unless you want it to look freaking awesome afterwards😉. Besides, their shop is all the way down in Central Point...
Seriously, if it’s only appearance, why not fish it, then repair it once the season slows down? Make up your mind then about how pretty you want it to be.
"Only the mediocre are always at their best" - Andy Capp